Skip to content
ShippingRecipesJoin the excellence

Italian Excellence, Authentic Refinement, Inimitable Tradition

Orders at +39 06 4008 5062 | WhatsApp

  • About Us
  • Shop All
  • Olive Oil
  • Oil-Preserved Foods
  • Jam Selection
  • Spreadable Cream
  • Shipping
  • Recipes
  • Join the excellence
Log in
No account yet? Create Account
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
RefineatRefineatRefineatRefineat
  • About Us
  • Shop All
  • Olive Oil
  • Oil-Preserved Foods
  • Jam Selection
  • Spreadable Cream
Search

Research

Account
Log in Create Account
Cart
00 items
Home
Gastronomic Experiences
How to recognize a good Extra Virgin Olive Oil

How to recognize a good Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Let's talk about olive oil, its history, its varieties, how to recognize quality oil and how it is one of the key ingredients of Italian cuisine.

Updated on  January 21, 2025
Come riconoscere un buon Olio Extravergine di Oliva

Extra virgin olive oil (EVO) is at the heart of the Mediterranean diet, beloved for its unique flavor and numerous health benefits. However, with so many oils available, it can be a challenge to distinguish a top-quality product. In this guide, we'll help you identify a high-quality extra virgin olive oil by analyzing its visual, olfactory, and taste characteristics, as well as essential label information.

The Main Classifications of Olive Oil

To make an informed choice, it is important to know the different categories of oil:

  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVO): obtained exclusively by mechanical processes, without the use of chemical substances, with free acidity ≤ 0.8%. It has a fruity flavor, free from sensory defects.
  • Virgin Olive Oil: similar to EVO, but with acidity up to 2% and possible organoleptic defects.
  • Refined Olive Oil: obtained from virgin oils through refining, with neutral flavour and aroma.
  • Olive Pomace Oil: produced by refining the residue from olive pressing, often mixed with virgin oil.

Visual Analysis: Color and Clarity

The color of EVO oil can vary from deep green to golden yellow, influenced by the variety of olives, the degree of ripeness and the extraction method. However, color is not a sure indicator of quality, since it can be modified by filtration or the addition of chlorophyll.

Clarity is another important aspect. Unfiltered oils may have a slight turbidity due to suspended particles, without compromising quality. On the contrary, excessively clear oils may have been refined, losing part of their organoleptic properties.

Olfactory Evaluation: Perfume and Aromas

A quality EVO oil releases a fruity, fresh and inviting aroma. Among the most common olfactory notes are hints of freshly cut grass, artichoke, tomato, almond and apple. Unpleasant odors, such as rancid, mold or fermentation, are clear indicators of low quality.

Taste Test: Flavor and Sensations

Tasting is essential to evaluate an EVO oil. An excellent product offers a harmonious balance between bitterness and spiciness, resulting from the presence of beneficial phenolic compounds. The fruity flavor may include notes of grass, artichoke, tomato or almond.

Bitterness and pungency, although they can vary in intensity, are positive signs of freshness. On the contrary, metallic or wet cardboard flavors indicate oxidation or unwanted fermentation.

Tag: What to Check

The label is a valuable source of information about the quality of the oil. Here are the elements to check:

  • Name: Make sure it says "Extra Virgin Olive Oil".
  • Origin: prefer oils with DOP (Protected Designation of Origin) or IGP (Protected Geographical Indication).
  • Harvest or Expiration Date: choose fresh oils, to be consumed within 18 months of production.
  • Extraction Method: the term "cold extracted" guarantees a process at temperatures ≤ 27°C.
  • Olive Varieties: Knowing the cultivar helps predict the flavor profile.

Storage and Packaging

Storage significantly affects the quality of EVO oil:

  • Packaging: Prefer dark glass bottles or stainless steel containers.
  • Storage: Keep oil away from light, heat and oxygen.
  • Closure: Make sure the container is airtight.

Certifications and Awards

Certifications such as DOP, IGP and Organic attest to the excellence of the product. International awards, such as the "Sol d'Oro" or the "NYIOOC World Olive Oil Competition", are further indicators of quality.

The Frost Test

A home method to evaluate an EVO oil is the freeze test: put the oil in the refrigerator and observe if it solidifies. This behavior, typical of monounsaturated fatty acids, is common in quality oils. However, it is not foolproof, as even inferior oils can show the same behavior.

Beware of Prices That Are Too Low

An authentic EVO oil requires high production costs. Prices that are too low often hide inaccurate blends or production processes.

Conclusion

Recognizing a high-quality extra virgin olive oil requires attention to detail. Analyzing color, aroma, flavor and label allows you to make an informed choice. An excellent EVO oil is not only a pleasure for the palate, but an investment in health. Remember, each bottle tells a story of tradition and passion: choose with curiosity and awareness.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Other articles

Il pesto alla genovese: storia, tradizione e il segreto per un gusto autentico

Genoese Pesto: History, Tradition, and the Secret to an Authentic Taste

February 07, 2025
La conservazione sott’olio: tradizione e gusto italiano

Preserving Food in Oil: Italian Tradition and Flavor

January 24, 2025
‘Nduja calabrese: specialità piccante della tradizione italiana

'Nduja: Spicy Specialty of the Italian Tradition

January 23, 2025
Who we are
  • Research and Recovery of Traditions
  • Our History
  • 100% Italian products
  • The Value of Craftsmanship
  • A Unique Culinary Experience
Who we are
  • Research and Recovery of Traditions
  • Our History
  • 100% Italian products
  • The Value of Craftsmanship
  • A Unique Culinary Experience
Selections
  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Oil-Preserved Foods
  • Jam Selection
  • Spreadable Creams
Selections
  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Oil-Preserved Foods
  • Jam Selection
  • Spreadable Creams
Luxury Venues
  • Restaurants
  • Club
  • Yacht
  • Golf Club
  • Yacht Club
Luxury Venues
  • Restaurants
  • Club
  • Yacht
  • Golf Club
  • Yacht Club
Contacts
  • Telephone orders
  • Whatsapp
  • Customer Service
  • Email contact
  • Feedback
Contacts
  • Telephone orders
  • Whatsapp
  • Customer Service
  • Email contact
  • Feedback
Various
  • Change shipping country
  • Limited availability
  • Gastronomic experiences
  • Credits
Various
  • Change shipping country
  • Limited availability
  • Gastronomic experiences
  • Credits
REFINEAT

Refineat trades Italian culinary excellence, selected by companies that preserve ancient recipes and use artisanal methods. 100% Italian products and handcrafted.

REFINEAT

Refineat trades Italian culinary excellence, selected by companies that preserve ancient recipes and use artisanal methods. 100% Italian products and handcrafted.

RefineatRefineat
© Tutti i diritti riservati: Refineat | Italy – P. IVA IT 17661721005
  • Italy (EUR €)
  • United States (USD $)
  • English
  • Italiano
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Cart

0 items

Your Cart is Empty

Loading...

Shop Now
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.